Showing posts with label ontology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ontology. Show all posts

Friday, March 4, 2011

Make-up Journal #2

Ah yes, another make up journal for the ones I missed before I was in the class.
Yesterday, I got the opportunity to talk to professor Ostraff from the art department. He spoke to me about how in Tonga, they don't even have a word specifically for "art." This makes sense, in that pretty much everything that people do is art. The way we walk or talk, the clothes we wear, how we style our hair... even things like cars, shoes, pillows, architecture etc they are all some sort of art, and it's such a broad and generally term that the word doesn't even mean anything! The things that people do that are creative can also have a utility, and at the same time things we use for utility can have aesthetics to which we can ascribe artistic qualities.
I like that Tonga doesn't have a word for art, in that, everything they do is art so there just isn't a word for "everything you can do." It makes a lot of sense.
As I go to Tonga, I am studying the weaving houses, and the women create art, but it's also their "job" or source of income, at the same time it's a social space where she can spend time with her family and/or friends, and at the same time, it's traditional and cultural, and the cloths will be used for important ceremonies or for gift giving. When you look at it this way, it's clear to see why there isn't a word for "art," because everything is sort of woven together (pun definitely intended). In Tonga, the womens relationships to the cloth is so much more than just a way to make money, or a form of art. It's multi-dimensional and it's super beautiful. I am excited to be able to take a closer look at what all that is like in the weaving houses!

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

January 19

This morning I got the opportunity to talk to one of my professors about my research project and it got me thinking about a lot of ideas that I had for my research. I wanted to focus my study on marriage and family specifically toward women, and he gave me an interesting topic. He talked about how I can study motherhood and then compare it to the western/modern ideas of parenting here in the US.
Coming onto this project as a sociologist wanting to do an ethnographic study, it was hard for me to justify my research into something that would be not only meaningful but interesting for people to read. If I do a study of the Tongan lifestyle, a society we would not consider especially "modern" and then use that as a commentary on our society in the US as modernists, then I could make interesting statements on society and lifestyle.
So, more about the topic, we talked about how women in the US have a very privatized style of parenting. This is where each mother is responsible for her children and no one else's, and does not necessarily want other people "raising" her children since she wants to do it her "right" way. Dallin discussed how in Tonga children are raised communally and parents take care of, shelter and even feed other people's children. I read an article about how Tongans consider themselves weaved together just the cloth they weave. Not only to people aroung them in the community but to their ancestory as well. Maybe the people in Tonga don't necessarily act as rational, individualistic beings. Maybe they look at themselves in relation to others, whether this be their parents, grandparents, or simply the people around them with whom they associate with. In the United States the modernists are primarily rational individualistic where people pursue the means to a desired end and act according to their desires.
This way of looking yourselves affects the way you look at parenting. this is interesting because in the US only biological (or adoptive) parents are allowed to teach their children, discipline them and instill values and religious beliefs on them. This goes along with the individualistic rational approach to life, and your children are simply your means to a certain end, whether to bring another person in the world just like you, or simply to fufill societal duties and expectations of raising a family.
Comparing our society to a society like Tonga might be problematic since Tonga is much more homogeneous than the United States where backgrounds, cultures, and beliefs are extremely varied. Not only that, the culture of US being over sensitive over their beliefs is part of the reason why parents are so privatized over their child rearing. It could also be why teachers and schools of the public sort cannot, in any way, discuss religion or moral beliefs for fear of "offending" a parent who wishes to instill different values in their child.
Perhaps the best way of looking at this is questioning our ideals of parenting. Perhaps the worst way of raising a child is to drill one set of beliefs and not allow them to explore other options. Such a close-minded way of raising a child probably results in closed-minded people who believe there is only one right way of doing things. It will be interesting to see what kinds of effects the Tongan lifestyle of parenting has on children.
Another interesting topic we discussed was the modernists perception of time. Dallin spoke to me about how Tongan’s have a different perception of time. Sometimes the people just didn’t follow through on appointments etc. In the US our society is so glued to our watches and have a strict schedule that follows time by the very second. This is a way of organizing life in a way that we can “maximize” our potential and get the most done. The modernist would argue that this is the best way to order society however looking at another perception of time might argue against such enslavement to a unit of measurement.
From a religious perspective, time is something man-made. In order to organize days and in an effort to control the sun rising and setting, people have a set clock and even daylight savings time in order to maximize on sunlight etc. This is interesting because God has no time. He is yesterday, today and forever. Maybe the best kind of lifestyle isn’t necessarily one that is strict on clocks and time.
Anyway, these were just some interesting topics that go along on the path which I wanted to study. Studying tonga isn’t necessarily looking at a primitive society and seeing how they are going to evolve into what we consider “modernism.” In fact, I would argue against that. Tonga has its own modernity in and of itself. So rather than looking at Tonga as a “time machine” and criticize modernism, I want to look at is as sort of an alternative modernism. Because the way that we are right now isn’t the way we have to be. We can't study people as objects that are contained in and of themselves. People are changing, and studies of them have to reflect changes and the idea of "becoming" rather than people as they "are."

Friday, January 14, 2011

January 14

Last night I got the opportunity to interview someone who had lived in Tonga for 2 years for his LDS mission. I asked him about the lifestyle there, and about family lives. He said a lot of women spend their time taking care of the homes and then make tapa cloth and weave, which they usually sell for a profit. Then the men work out in "the bush." I told him that I am extremely interested in learning more about the social aspects of weaving that the women participate in. While weaving, the women talk about family life, stories, and even gossip. I'm looking into spending more time on researching this specific topic. I would love to do my research as an ethnography, and just write about what its like in Tonga to be in a group of women weaving all day together.
For my research, I'm definitely leaning toward a qualitative research study, but I have to give it some sort of validity. I'm not one to say that positivism and the scientific method gives us real "truth" or that there is one perfect way to give us unadulterated truth. My experiences in Tonga won't be the same as everyone else's, and it most certainly won't be the same as my friend who served his mission there. What gives validity to my research, then, is the argument against this "perfect way" of studying a people to find truth. Anyone who studies a people or culture will have their biases. As much as they try to avoid that, any person studying another culture only sees it through their perspective of "culture". There is no real way to eliminate our own perspective on our research. Therefore, as a qualitative study, my experiences aren't necessarily a scientific claim on what life is like there in Tonga or what "reality" is for the people in Tonga. I can't possibly know that, since I am not a native born Tongan. My claim is only to share what I discovered while there, in my involvement with the people and through my experiences as an outsider looking in through my empirical knowledge. I am in no way saying that my research will reflect the same research that has been done in Tonga or will be repeatable as a scientific experiment in the future. Those are just some thoughts I had on where I'm coming from in my research.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

January 12

Today in our class discussion, we talked about how to make a good research proposal. It pressured me to get on narrowing my research project so that I can start preparing for my proposal. As a general idea, I want to study families and their interactions. I want to come into the field study as what I would call a "socioethnopoligist," where I combine sociological ontological assumptions when approaching my research, and study as an anthropoligist in that I will participate in life in order to experience it and understand it more, and then to write up my research as more of an ethnography of family life in Tonga. Specifically, I'm very interested in women in society, and how their roles affect family life. In class my group discussed how I can narrow my topic by looking at one aspect of the women's life, such as tapa weaving, and then see how it affects family life or perceptions on what family is and how its structured. I'm very excited to do more research in order to really dig deep into what I want to study.