I've been reading Black Like Me. The author, Griffin, relays his stories about when he changed his appearance to look Black and lived in the south. His methods include interviews and participant observation in order to gather data and share what it would be like to be Black. Many questions arise as to how legitimate and objective his methods are and how reliable his data is. How much of his writings can we pass off as actual data that we can use as information on what it was really like to be Black? How much of his methods were actually ethical?
His novel begins with how he made himself appear to be black, and I hesitate to say that he actually turned Black; many might say that this novel is about when Mr. Griffin “turned’ black. However, I disagree with that terminology and will argue that while he only changed his appearance to appear to be Black, he did not actually become Black. While he experienced what it was like to be treated as a Black man, he could never actually know what it was really like to BE a Black man. His visage of a Black man was one that he could take off, and especially during the last part of the experience, when he changed from Black to White whenever it was convenient for him.
As for ethics, he did admit that he was actually a white professor whenever someone was suspicious, however he only does this once or twice throughout his 6 weeks. Most people he talked to were being deceived into sharing things with this white man that they probably wouldn't have shared otherwise. In reality, his project would definitely not be IRB approved. But, that's not to say that what he did wasn't helpful for the humanities, in that his story gives people a tiny glimpse of what it was like to be black in the 50s. As for his data, I would say that although its a good story but maybe not scientifically or academically rigorous.
As for my research, I'll be living among these women who might look a little like me, but I will always be a foreigner in the way that I look at them and research about them. I will try to fit in and immerse myself in the culture and customs, however I think that from an objective point of view, like the outsider, but still on the inside (through participating and observing) is a good perspective to have for research, in that you can be objective and you're not too involved to the point that you can't interpret and bring back scientific data.
Showing posts with label research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label research. Show all posts
Friday, April 8, 2011
Monday, March 28, 2011
March 26
Today we talked about concerns that we had about going into the field.
I'm not a huge worrysome person, and I just go with the flow, and I'm just flexible like that! All this planning before-hand for I'm supposed to be doing for the next 5 months is way hard because I have no idea what I'm doing in the next 5 days!
So, whenever they ask a question about "what would you do if..." I just roll my eyes and think "I'll figure it out when I get there!" Additionally, all these "what ifs" are completely situation and dependent on the circumstances.
But then Ashley asked us a question about how would we notice the needs of others and be able to respond to them. How will we know when we see a need that needs fufilling? Do you ever notice the needs of others? Do you ever notice what kinds of things you never notice?
After she asked us that the whole group kind of went silent and I knew I didn't have an answer and I don't think anyone else did. I guess I never notice what I don't try to notice.
So, for the next week I want to try to notice the things that I never notice. I want to see if I can pick up on other people's needs and anything else I would never pick up on. I know that if I am keeping a watchful eye out for specific things I would normally ignore, then I can get a good feel and practice what it's like and be able to do it in the field.
This will be good for my field study, in that I will be able to better see the needs of others, be able to serve more, and be able to reciprocate appropriately for my host family and that way I don't look like a total jerk in Tonga! I will report how I improve/notice more things next week!
I'm not a huge worrysome person, and I just go with the flow, and I'm just flexible like that! All this planning before-hand for I'm supposed to be doing for the next 5 months is way hard because I have no idea what I'm doing in the next 5 days!
So, whenever they ask a question about "what would you do if..." I just roll my eyes and think "I'll figure it out when I get there!" Additionally, all these "what ifs" are completely situation and dependent on the circumstances.
But then Ashley asked us a question about how would we notice the needs of others and be able to respond to them. How will we know when we see a need that needs fufilling? Do you ever notice the needs of others? Do you ever notice what kinds of things you never notice?
After she asked us that the whole group kind of went silent and I knew I didn't have an answer and I don't think anyone else did. I guess I never notice what I don't try to notice.
So, for the next week I want to try to notice the things that I never notice. I want to see if I can pick up on other people's needs and anything else I would never pick up on. I know that if I am keeping a watchful eye out for specific things I would normally ignore, then I can get a good feel and practice what it's like and be able to do it in the field.
This will be good for my field study, in that I will be able to better see the needs of others, be able to serve more, and be able to reciprocate appropriately for my host family and that way I don't look like a total jerk in Tonga! I will report how I improve/notice more things next week!
Monday, March 14, 2011
March 14
So my project has taken a slight turn. My focus instead of families will be westernization in Tonga. As young women in Tonga, they experience the cultural traditions of weaving, but at the same time are experiencing westernization in Tonga. Tonga is still a monarchy, but theres been a push for democracy, a very western idea. Additionally, other western aspects of culture are taking over, and a lot of the people think that the Palangi (white) way is better. I really want to look at what kinds of perspectives that these women have who experience traditional aspects of the culture and what they think about western influences in Tonga.
Tuesday, February 22, 2011
February 22
Today we had a reading about rapport and access to the communities in which we are going to study. A few things I learned that I need to go is be friendly and charming in order to gain people's trust in order to be able to get good data for my research. It really helps that I am a woman studying women, considering men might not be willing to open up to me, and women would feel more comfortable sharing things with me. In addition to that, I will be able to gain access to the all-women working houses. In order to gain access to my community, I am relying mostly on my relationship with my host mother and sisters. I am hoping that through my relationship with them, I can get to work in the houses and make tapa or gnatu and be able to get references to other work houses as well to get as much data as I can. Another thing I'm doing to build rapport is I'm trying to learn the language. This will help because people will know that I am truly interested in them and that I want to learn.
Due to my short time in the field, I have to be able to gain access and trust as soon as possible in order to get as much data as I can. When I went to the Tongan ward, people were so friendly and inviting. I am hoping that the Tongans will be open and willing to share their culture and lives with me for a short time so that I can bring back what I have learned and be able to share it with everybody here.
Due to my short time in the field, I have to be able to gain access and trust as soon as possible in order to get as much data as I can. When I went to the Tongan ward, people were so friendly and inviting. I am hoping that the Tongans will be open and willing to share their culture and lives with me for a short time so that I can bring back what I have learned and be able to share it with everybody here.
Friday, February 4, 2011
Interview
I didn't know about the assignment until it was way to late to find a Tongan person and interview them :( So, I used a friend who served in Tonga on his mission.
The interview conducted was an informal, semi constructed question/answer session. I will outline the things he said about the culture.
FAMILY LIFE-
Men and women have different responsibilities. Men go to the bush and work during the day. Women take care of the home and the children and go to weaving houses during the day to weave or make gnatu. They make these in large groups and sell them to people for weddings, funerals, births and even to tourists. He mentioned that the women just sit there and discuss whatever comes to mind. It's their main source of social interaction. Something interesting he said is that entire communities raise all the children together and everyone is willing to punish, discipline, feed and shelter any child. They also tend to give their children to other family members who don't have any. This sort of communal child raising technique is extremely interesting. Comparatively, in the US, parenting is extremely privatized and women especially want to be the only ones to influence and raise their child. This sort of way is very ethnocentric and I would argue that if affects the child's ability to open up to other things. The Tongan people practically live the consecration not just in family relations but in possessions as well. My interviewee told me not to be surprised when someone asks me for something of mine. And of course, I have to give it to them. I was a little concerned over this, because it's just in my culture that people own and possess their items and that's that. It's kind of like a little child playing with his sibling, and one wants a toy but the other says "it's mine!" This is interesting because when you think about it, the toys probably weren't purchased by them, and I'm sure the toy actually belongs to the parents who purchased them, and even they would argue that the toy is for both of them. It's kind of a silly and selfish way to live, if you think about it.
I asked him about food, specifically if I would lose weight on the trip.
He said we would eat a lot of roots and probably some fruit, but not a whole lot of meat which is reserved for special occasions. He said I should expect to have diarrhea a lot. He said he gained weight on his mission, but I don't really like sweet potatoes or yams so I'm banking on losing some weight! He said the fruit was so amazing, especially pineapple when they are in season. He said they would eat it til their tongues were bleeding.
I asked him about differences between LDS families and non LDS families.
He said that there wasn't that much of a difference, especially considering even those that are not LDS are still Christian. He said the biggest difference was probably alcohol consumption.
He showed me his tohi a molomona and I read a couple verses out of it while he checked my Tongan pronunciation. He said it wasn't all that bad!
He also showed me his ta'ovala, which are the traditional waist mats that Tongan's wear to special occasions. I tried it on and I have to admit I looked good.
He told me some stories about when he was there, which were wonderful. But, concerning my project I've included what's important for living there as a guest and then what's applicable to my research.
The interview conducted was an informal, semi constructed question/answer session. I will outline the things he said about the culture.
FAMILY LIFE-
Men and women have different responsibilities. Men go to the bush and work during the day. Women take care of the home and the children and go to weaving houses during the day to weave or make gnatu. They make these in large groups and sell them to people for weddings, funerals, births and even to tourists. He mentioned that the women just sit there and discuss whatever comes to mind. It's their main source of social interaction. Something interesting he said is that entire communities raise all the children together and everyone is willing to punish, discipline, feed and shelter any child. They also tend to give their children to other family members who don't have any. This sort of communal child raising technique is extremely interesting. Comparatively, in the US, parenting is extremely privatized and women especially want to be the only ones to influence and raise their child. This sort of way is very ethnocentric and I would argue that if affects the child's ability to open up to other things. The Tongan people practically live the consecration not just in family relations but in possessions as well. My interviewee told me not to be surprised when someone asks me for something of mine. And of course, I have to give it to them. I was a little concerned over this, because it's just in my culture that people own and possess their items and that's that. It's kind of like a little child playing with his sibling, and one wants a toy but the other says "it's mine!" This is interesting because when you think about it, the toys probably weren't purchased by them, and I'm sure the toy actually belongs to the parents who purchased them, and even they would argue that the toy is for both of them. It's kind of a silly and selfish way to live, if you think about it.
I asked him about food, specifically if I would lose weight on the trip.
He said we would eat a lot of roots and probably some fruit, but not a whole lot of meat which is reserved for special occasions. He said I should expect to have diarrhea a lot. He said he gained weight on his mission, but I don't really like sweet potatoes or yams so I'm banking on losing some weight! He said the fruit was so amazing, especially pineapple when they are in season. He said they would eat it til their tongues were bleeding.
I asked him about differences between LDS families and non LDS families.
He said that there wasn't that much of a difference, especially considering even those that are not LDS are still Christian. He said the biggest difference was probably alcohol consumption.
He showed me his tohi a molomona and I read a couple verses out of it while he checked my Tongan pronunciation. He said it wasn't all that bad!
He also showed me his ta'ovala, which are the traditional waist mats that Tongan's wear to special occasions. I tried it on and I have to admit I looked good.
He told me some stories about when he was there, which were wonderful. But, concerning my project I've included what's important for living there as a guest and then what's applicable to my research.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)